Epistemic partiality in friendship

Author: gxiq

August undefined, 2024

WebChapter 2, “Reframing Epistemic Partiality,” applies my account of acceptance to a specific debate in the ethics of belief: the epistemic partiality debate, which asks whether we sometimes ought to believe against the evidence regarding our friends. Though compelling, the partialist view has been plagued by serious objections. WebApr 13, 2024 · A Faith-Based Account of Epistemic Partiality in Friendship Much work has been done in contemporary epistemology to reconcile our epistemic ideals with our …

(PDF) Friendship and Epistemic Norms - ResearchGate

WebStroud Epistemic Partiality in Friendship 499 either to the detriment of particular moral theories, such as utilitari-anism, or against the claims of morality in general. This article does not directly contribute to those debates about the relation between friend-ship and morality. Rather, it pursues an analogous yet, so far as I know, WebApr 13, 2024 · A Faith-Based Account of Epistemic Partiality in Friendship Much work has been done in contemporary epistemology to reconcile our epistemic ideals with our human need for healthy relationships with our loved ones. Ryan Preston-Roedder makes an attempt to resolve the tension between these two goals in his paper, “Three Varieties of … the ninth inning

The epistemic demands of friendship: friendship as

WebSimon Keller and Sarah Stroud argue that good friendship not only often accompanies such differential epistemic practices, but also demand them at least sometimes. Good friendship, they say, sometimes demands some sort of epistemic partiality that is objectionable from an epistemic point of view. WebApr 1, 2006 · Epistemic Partiality in Friendship Authors: Sarah Stroud No full-text available Citations (152) ... 7 The apparent tension between practical and evidential … WebStroud Epistemic Partiality in Friendship501 more famous (or infamous) for its sweeping rejection of modern ethical theories, is also important methodologically for the prominent role it gives to the kind of phenomenological analysis of friendship for which I have just … michelson\\u0027s interferometer

On the Epistemic Costs of Friendship: Against the Encroachment …

Epistemic Partiality in Friendship* Sarah Stroud - JSTOR

WebSep 1, 2012 · Finally, some sceptics about epistemic partialism have suggested that it goes wrong from the start, by accepting a mistaken view of friendship. (See Badhwar (1993), … WebStroud Epistemic Partiality in Friendship501 more famous (or infamous) for its sweeping rejection of modern ethical theories, is also important methodologically for the prominent … michelson\\u0027s needhamWebApr 14, 2024 · In this paper, I expand on Preston-Roedder’s ideas, distilling a novel account of epistemic partiality that allows us to maintain epistemic rationality without sacrificing … michelson\\u0027s lexington ma

"WebJul 14, 2024 · One of these debates concerns the epistemic partiality of friendship. In certain circumstances, we tend to evaluate the same evidence differently depending on whether it concerns a friend or a non-friend. Some scholars argue that this sort of epistemic partiality is irrational (Slote (2013)) while others consider it rationally justifiable ... " - Epistemic partiality in friendship

Epistemic partiality in friendship

WebMay 30, 2024 · 1 Epistemic partiality in friendship: the problem Being someone’s friend or loved one affects how you interact with the person: we treat our intimates differently than … WebIt has been alleged that the demands of friendship conflict with the norms of epistemology—in particular, that there are cases in which the moral demands of …

Did you know?

WebEpistemic reasons are reasons for believing in a proposition through being facts which are part of a case for (belief in) its truth (call such considerations ‘truth-related’). These maxims (as I shall call them) have proved controversial. Confining myself to the epistemic maxim two clarifications and one argument may help.

WebOct 17, 2002 · Special obligations are obligations owed to some subset of persons, in contrast to natural duties that are owed to all persons simply qua persons. Common sense morality seems to understand us as having special obligations to those to whom we stand in some sort of special relationship, e.g., our friends, our family members, our colleagues, … Webepistemic partiality in friendship, but also presents a possible way forward in our thinking about other occasions of epistemic partiality and belief-regulation more generally. Third, this thesis helps uncover a tension between moral, pragmatic, and epistemic norms. The case of epistemic partiality in friendship gives us reason to believe that ...

WebAug 1, 2024 · This paper develops an action-oriented alternative to the alethic approach to epistemological inquiry, an alternative that is inspired by and jives with the kind of thinking that underwrites promising and increasingly popular enactive or embodied research programs in cognitive science. Expand 3 View 1 excerpt Save Alert WebAug 18, 2024 · Epistemic Partiality in Friendship* Sarah Stroud Philosophy Ethics 2006 Analytic moral philosophers have been taking a renewed interest in friendship in recent years. They have been especially liable to consider friendship in connection with debates over partiality and… Expand 173

WebThe epistemic demands of friendship: friendship as inherently knowledge-involving. Synthese 199 (1-2):2439-2455. Copy BIBTEX Abstract Many recent philosophers have …

WebApr 1, 2006 · Epistemic Partiality in Friendship*. Analytic moral philosophers have been taking a renewed interest in friendship in recent years. They have been especially … michelson\\u0027s office rockford ilWebIn “Friendship and Epistemic Norms,” Jason Kawall advances an argument for pragmatic encroachment as a solution of the friendship dilemma.4 I present a modified version of … the ninth life of a diamond minerWebJul 26, 2024 · Defenders of the “encroachment strategy” argue that exemplary friends who are especially slow to believe that their friends have acted wrongly are simply sensitive to the high prudential or moral costs of falsely believing in their friends’ guilt. michelson\\u0027s bakery bonita springsWebAug 1, 2024 · It has been alleged that the demands of friendship conflict with the norms of epistemology—in particular, that there are cases in which the moral demands of friendship would require one to give... the ninth labor of herculesWebMost recently, he has been thinking about the fittingness of anger about past wrongdoing, the epistemic partiality of friendship, and the concept of a moral judgment. Apart from philosophy, Michael enjoys sports (especially involving water) and music (especially involving wind instruments). michelson\\u0027s needham massWebEpistemic partiality and value commitments. In The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of Friendship. In The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of … the ninth life of a diamond miner: a memoirWebSyntax; Advanced Search; New. All new items; Books; Journal articles; Manuscripts; Topics. All Categories; Metaphysics and Epistemology michelson\\u0027s paducah